Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Karl Sanchez's avatar

First comment: At the SPIEF, Putin said the economic condition in March was far from certain. There was confidence, but no assurances. IMO, the feint to Kiev forced negotiations that would've been favorable for Russia and Ukraine. But they were nixed on orders from Team Biden carried by Bojo. Why? Because Crimea has always been the Empire's goal and that still seemed feasible since the economic war had yet to really take hold in Western eyes, and that was always the major consideration. Plus, the self-induced illusion of Russia's weakness was in full control. And as we well know, Neocons don't give in easily. Russia's quick military technical operation gambit came very close to succeeding but didn't, which forced a repositioning and reappraisal.

Now that I've read the whole piece, first, the slaughter was expected and will continue. Yes, it's horrifying for me as a former soldier, but I anticipated it, so it's not altogether surprising. Second, on your translation issue, I got the right translation from the outset and have several ideas of what might come next to create several additional facts on the ground, which I'll share when I have greater time to comment. Third, there's still a channel to ford to get to the ZNPP; and as I commented before, any attempted assault will have worse results than those you chronicled in this report. Fourth, on all the military equipment movement, it's the time of year for Reserve and National Guard Summer FTXs, so some will be that sort of thing. If Biden were to try and commit US troops, IMO he'll get impeached ASAP. The only aid that makes sense is using other NATO troops to man NATO armor that's in cantonment in Europe; but without air support, that will be another futile attempt that will fail. As I commented a month ago, it's either ALL-IN or surrender as continuing piece-meal additions is "military malpractice" as Larry Johnson said.

I have comments on Russia's space program and a report on the state of the EU/EC/NATO's fate in Europe, but I'll need to add them when I have more time to write. Again, thanks for your efforts; I don't bother seeking out other perspectives because I don't need to!

Expand full comment
Sam Ursu's avatar

Thank you for yet another superbly accurate and comprehensive analysis.

A couple of comments:

1) Let's not forget that the SBU straight up murdered Denis Kireev (last name has multiple spelling variants in English) who was the Ukrainian guy who negotiated the agreement that Putin was showing the African leaders this weekend. Now it's clear why - Zelensky et al were embarrassed that they signed those docs in the first place and had to cover it up.

2) Putin also showed the guests at SPIEF a video on the origins of the OUN and Bandera cult, which certainly shocked a number of people in the audience, who didn't realize just how bad it was (even in the context of WW2 and Nazi concentration camps, this was some truly sick shit).

2b) By the way, Bandera wasn't just a lunatic racist, he was a severely disturbed individual who tortured and killed cats as a child to "impress" the other kids in his village. Ugh.

3) The village of Pyatikhaki literally means "five huts" or "five shacks," which tells you just how tiny it is, and yet hundreds if not thousands of guys are dying to capture it. Ooof, what a tragedy.

4) As you previously noted, the Russian MoD is beyond meticulous in recording kills. And yes, they're paying huge bonuses for equipment destroyed, so for a lot of Russian soldiers right now, it's jackpot time. I saw a Kornet team get a Leopard kill and they were jumping up and down with happiness because of the bonus, so damn straight, I believe Ukie crews are now doing literally everything possible to avoid driving Leopards out onto the battlefield.

5) Not mentioned by you, but looks like the reports of Challengers in the field (in Ukraine) were bogus, with the video taken from an earlier exercise in Estonia (with British crews).

6) Speaking of African leaders, Putin also agreed to ship ~700 million tons of wheat for free to Egypt, which is doing a hell of a lot more to buy goodwill than whatever nonsense the US is doing. Egypt, btw, eats a lot of wheat bread, and all of it is distributed at below cost by the government, so this is a pretty major deal.

7) The people of Odessa are now fighting back against those recruitment officers who keep press ganging people off the street. Bravo!

8) Totally unrelated to Ukraine, but I sure am glad to see the conflict in Sudan taking a pause with an agreed-upon ceasefire.

Expand full comment
415 more comments...

No posts