606 Comments
User's avatar
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 19
Comment deleted
TJE's avatar

and how EXACTLY - state in detail - is Russia supposed to "rubble" Ukranus?

Frantic's avatar

As of recently, I am taking a certain delight in winning this race from time to time

Frantic's avatar

Frontlines are finally moving at a good pace, Russia stopped the AFU local counterattacks near Komar at the Dnepropetrovsk oblast border with Donbass, Kramatorsk is being approached from the east with little to no hamlet left inbetween, both Orekhov and Dobropillyia have been infiltrated with a stable presence, there are Ukrainian units trapped in a fire-control-with-drone pocket which formed east of Volchansk, north of Velikyi Burluk and south of the border: why Simplicius, why by now since the year 2026 started have you decided to shut down all your frontline reporting, instead limiting your insightful gaze to analyses of the home fronts, of the daily strike warfare over civilian structures, and over the tiresome media soap operas and the politics circus spectacle?

thatguy's avatar

I recall quite a few articles where Simplicius has gone into detail about frontline activities in 2026, so I think you are overstating it here.

But yes, there has been a notable shift in focus over time. I think a big part of it is that many people find that the slow progress on the frontlines makes for very repetetive "sitreps", and this does become a little boring to read after 4.5 years. Especially with all the other developments going on.

We're going to get what Simplicius decides to give us, and like it! I could do without so much of the tedious writing about the US political and Trump clown show myself, frankly.

Frantic's avatar

A gardening substack is actually awesome. I'll check it out thoroughly

Sam's avatar

sitreps are my favourite would love detailed ones more often

Glasshopper's avatar

Indeed. This is why I rarely watch Alexander Mercouris any more. David Lean length daily sitreps are not much fun or interesting.

Frantic's avatar

Nah these people are grifting copycats of Simplicius.

Jeannie's avatar

Watch the ones he does together with Alex Cristiforo, because they are much more to the point.

Tim's avatar

I listen to Mercouris if I want to fall deeply asleep within five minutes or less.

Christoferou is a lot more interesting though.

Frantic's avatar

> "I recall quite a few articles where Simplicius has gone into detail about frontline activities in 2026"

You can count them on the finger of one of your hands. These pieces were objectively curter and less informative than the sitreps from previous years. Also, until recently Simplicius made sure sitreps were never behind the paywall

> "We're going to get what Simplicius decides to give us, and like it! I could do without so much of the tedious writing about the US political and Trump clown show"

Sadly, it could be argued Simplicius saw the bizarre posturing of Trump in the middle east and the subsequent long-range strike exchanges with Iran (wouldn't call those proper 'wars'), as an opportunity to diversify his output. To put this groundbreaking decision for the blog in perspective, he did not consider a change of format even when Israel invaded Gaza in 2023, instead keeping the publication of his traditional Ukraine war sitreps intact.

Now, naturally I am aware Simplicius started his career by chronicling the skirmishing in Syria against Kurds and Turks, on Saker's blog. He might feel nostalgic of the desert landscapes and setting. This hypothesis is reinforced by the observation that he never cared about chronicling similarly ragged African conflicts in Sudan, Sahel, Congo-Ruanda that are currently still raging on.

But with all the format and topic experimentation he is been doing lately, he might risk breaking something that previously worked. The focus - in my humble opinion - should be on events in the Ukrainian frontlines, followed by the strike warfare between Ukraine and Russia, followed by tactics and strategic considerations of military commanders as found on telegram, by the press and based on Simplicius' own opinion, then he should cover novel weaponry and technology developments which for many is the most interesting and exciting topic, then should cover the political situation in Russia and Ukraine and NATO. Beyond this yes, he could slip a final section where he updates on the latest Trump's tweet on truth social, or whatever missile was launched or ship was seized in the Hormuz strait. But reorienting the whole blog to hinge around such crappy clickbait world events, well, meh!

And I believe I am being fair here.

Jeannie's avatar

Get your own substack, instead of pissing all over this wall.

TJE's avatar

nobody cares about african conflicts and nobody probably should

HL says Wagner is now a drug cartel in CAR which is lit if true

thatguy's avatar

Yes, absolutely fair and honest and moderately stated.

But pickers can't be choosers. I sometimes do get fed up with people constantly criticizing Simplicius. Sure, we all have complaints.

I still like this old aphorism: "if wishes were horses, beggars would ride".

Glenn Phillips's avatar

Mapping channels are BORING. They spend hours mincing over 20 sq km of territory all just to give idiot civilians who've never laced them up some talking points to make them feel like special boy warriors. In modern warfare it's all so tiresome.

GM's avatar

>Frontlines are finally moving at a good pace

What is a good pace?

There was what looked like acceleration a couple weeks ago, but it was almost entirely driven by the northeast Kharkov advance, and even that has stalled a bit now in the last week.

Everywhere else it's the same grind as usual. And if you quantify it in actual territory recovered, it is still substantially less than the peak tempo of late 2024.

Which was already inadequate because even at that peak tempo all of Ukraine would be liberated only some time in the early 22nd century. Now that has been pushed even further.

GM's avatar
Aug 19Edited

Here are the numbers from DivGen:

August 19:

➡️продвижение в Красноподолье (+1,1км2)

➡️продвижение в районе Волховки (+8,3км2)

➡️продвижение в Ковшаровке (+2,1км2)

August 18:

➡️освобождено Новосолошино (+12,8км2)

August 17:

➡️ВС РФ вошли в Купино (+10,3км2)

August 16:

➡️освобождено Рыбальское (+14,3км2)

➡️ВС РФ контролируют Мирное (+11,4км2)

➡️продвижение в направлении Новоандреевки (+14км2)

➡️освобождён н.п. Стенки (+0,9км2)

August 15:

➡️освобождена Новониколаевка (+7км2)

➡️освобождена Кудиевка (+3,8км2)

👉противник контролирует Поддубное и Зирку (-10,3км2)

➡️корректировка зоны контроля в пользу наших в полосе ответственности группировки войск «Восток» (+43,8км2)

August 14:

➡️ВС РФ контролируют Рогозное (+1,9км2)

August 13:

➡️освобождено Водяное (+2,1км2)

➡️освобождена Петровка (+5,8км2)

August 12:

➡️освобождена Щербаковка (+2,6км2)

➡️продвижение южнее Матяшево (+3,2км2)

➡️освобождён н.п. Новое Поле (+8,1км2)

👉противник контролирует н.п. Зарница (-8,6км2)

👉корректировка зоны контроля в пользу противника в районе Филии (-4,8км2)

August 11:

➡️продвижение севернее Константиновки (+7,7км2)

➡️продвижение южнее Доброполья (+0,5км2)

August 10:

➡️освобождено Торецкое (+1,5км2)

➡️освобождено Васютинское (+0,9км2)

➡️продвижение в н.п. Алексеево-Дружковка, Ижевка и Стенки (+4,0км2)

👉противник продвинулся в направлении н.п. Комар (-26,7км2)

August 9:

➡️освобождена Ивановка (+1,7км2)

➡️продвижение в районе Малой Волчьей (+0,5км2)

➡️продвижение в районе Щербаков (+48,9км2)

👉противник контролирует Приморское (-4,6км2)

August 8:

➡️освобождено Анищино (+8,6км2)

➡️продвижение у Новоподгороднего (+4км2)

➡️продвижение у Журавлёвки (+0,3км2)

August 7:

➡️продвижение у Дибровой и Озёрного (+6,6км2)

➡️продвижение у н.п. Горки (+8,4км2)

➡️освобождено Красноярское (+13,9км2)

➡️корректировка зоны контроля в пользу наших у Верхней Писаревки (+0,8км2)

➡️продвижение у Казачьей Лопани (+1,9км2)

August 6:

➡️освобождена Рыжевка (+8,3км2)

➡️освобождена Зарница (+19,1км2)

➡️корректировка зоны контроля в пользу наших у Бессаловки (+1,2км2)

August 5:

➡️освобождена Бакшеевка (+4,2км2)

➡️продвижение южнее н.п. Сопычь (+1,1км2)

August 4:

➡️освобождена Устиновка (+1,4км2)

➡️ВС РФ вошли в Матяшево (+0,8км2)

August 3:

➡️продвижение к н.п. Купино (+2,9км2)

August 2:

➡️продвижение в сторону Новониколаевки (+13,2км2)

➡️освобождено Любицкое (+19,8км2)

August 1:

➡️освобождён н.п. Веровка (+8,3км2)

➡️продвижение в районе Новомарково (+2,8км2)

➡️ВС РФ контролируют Кондрашовку (+1,2км2)

➡️продвижение севернее Рай-Александровки (+10,6км2)

Net daily advances:

11.5

12.8

10.3

40.6

44.3

1.9

7.9

0.5

8.2

-20.3

46.7

12.9

31.6

28.6

5.3

2.2

2.9

33

22.9

Average: 16 km^2 a day.

There are still some 480,000 km^2 under Ukro-NATO-Nazi control. At a rate of 16 km^2 a day, that means Ukraine will be liberated some time around the year 2110 at best. This assumes no deceleration down to gaining almost nothing every day as happened in the first half of 2026.

Meanwhile missiles and drones are flying all the way to Omsk, and highly sensitive objects are being hit every other day. Which timeline will reach the finish line first -- the timeline of the elimination of the proxy under the current absurd rules of engagement or the timeline of Russia no longer being able to fight because its industry and military have been destroyed by the NATO strategic bombing campaign?

CC's avatar

That’s it, thanks. This day I just read your commentary on the commentary and move on. It saves time.

LaVerne Karras's avatar

I'm not there, but what happens after the last Ukrainian defence line is breached, will the progress still be as slow?

Frantic's avatar

Still there is the real possibility they will be fighting in Kramatorsk much sooner than I expected. Progress has been solid and tangible.

Desmondo's avatar

"There's a snake in my boots!"

Abe's avatar
Aug 19Edited

NATO's current strategic bombing campaign against Russia through Ukrainen is lacking, they have not even begun to chink Russia's armor as far as dealing significant damage to Russia's military complexes.

Russia's three-layer air defense has been performing well in Moscow and in many of their more sensitive military targets. Russia prioritizes their sensitive military sites and they are well guarded. Need I remind you that just like in Ukraine, the soviet infrastructure for the military sites is very robust able to withstand higher payload strikes.

The fact is that the banderties have been sending thousands of mostly slow and low payload drones and only about 4% ever make it through should attest to that. Even Ukraine's Flamingo missiles are not as effective as your beloved western mainstream media wants you to believe.

Tim's avatar

GM has obviously never heard of the Butterfly Effect; ie a sudden small change is then superceded by a massive and final one.

This is how I see it - Ukraine is very close to final collapse now, especially since the destruction of the Odessa ports.

Frantic's avatar

For instance, Russians are carving a western pincer on Druzhkivka out of basically nowhere (totally unexpected by me) in the Donbass countryside between Dobropilliya and Kostantinovka. Happened in the last 3 or 4 days. Analogous strong pushes in Orekhov and on the Eastern approach from Gulyaipole where they cut through a motorway supplying Orekhov.

I mean, it's obviously still incremental pace, but definitely they woke up from their winter slumber and their spring torpor, when after having occupied Pokrovsk and Gulyaipole, absolutely nothing happened.

Certainly I understand rasputitsa in Spring and the lack of foliage cover in tree lines, but can all this be so paralysing? I haven't still come to a satisfying answer

GM's avatar
Aug 19Edited

There has been an increase in tempo since the catastrophic situation of six months ago, but the point is that this only brought things back to where they were previously, which was not a good situation to begin with.

P.S. Rasputitsa is not a factor currently because there are no large-scale mechanized assaults anyway, due to the drones.

Tim's avatar

The KGB has stated that the prize for winning is three years in a Siberian labour camp.

Be careful what you wish for - because you might get it.

But you will be able to meet and make friends with Victor and abcdefg.

Frantic's avatar

I scored a 19-hour commenting gap ahead of you. Be a good sport, fren

Tim's avatar

I was actually there 2 minutes after the post landed - my sleep patterns are pretty bad.

But knowing what I know, I didn't want undue attention from the KGB.

I've already done a five-year stretch, and it's cold, miserable, and you're always hungry.

Frantic's avatar

I give you 1% probability that it's true your life unfolded as you say it did

John Osman's avatar

The KGB dissolved in 1991.

Tim's avatar

"You're an idiot," John.

Kennewick Man's avatar

Every day is a holiday when ‘Zelensky Faces a New Political Challenge’.

mary-lou's avatar

"The Economist has sounded alarm..." < The Economist is a mouthpiece for the Rothschilds. are they admitting here their investments aren't working out the way they'd hoped for?

thatguy's avatar

The Economist isn't owned by the Rothschilds anymore. They sold their minority 26.9% stake in March 2026 to Canadian billionaire Stephen Smith and his family's financial holding company, Smith Financial.

LaVerne Karras's avatar

When you understand Canadian business you'll know that the shares were just transferred to a subsidiary, the ideology is still the same, you don't get to where he is without strong connections to certain groups.

Correction: a certain group

mary-lou's avatar

"mouthpiece" (different from 'owned').

The Spectre's avatar

Ukraine was a failed state for long. With bankruptcy of the national airline. And many state enterprises taken over for pennies by billionaires. With mass work migration for 30 years.

One of the reasons for it all is an endemic corruption.

Electing a stage comedian professional to presidential post shows level of politics. He is a puppet in hands of billionaires, nationalists/neo-fascists, foreign powers. Scott Ritter alleges Zelensky is an MI5 asset for long, in June 2023 he made 1h documentary "Agent Zelensky".

Corruption allows donors not only to control Ukrainian actors, but kickbacks from donations back to decision makers politicians gives them personal wealth and funds for their own electoral campaigns. Governmental funds are channeled that way to party politics. That's why Zelensky is so popular in American and European elites.

Being Jewish his whole team is also Jewish. They are preparing relocation of Israel to West Ukraine, after Israeli state will be destroyed.

Maquis's avatar

The Greater Khazaria Project.

Phillip Legard's avatar

One suspects that the primary lifeboat is now Argentina.

Maria.'s avatar

Many Israelis are metastasizing to Argentina

Montefrío the Curious's avatar

Milei is a very leaky vessel. A Zelensky-like dwarf whose principal electoral rival is another dwarf, Axel Kiciloff--a Jerry Lewis look-alike with sideburns like Milei--, assuming Milei makes it to the election next year. His behavior is increasingly erratic, he is sinking in the polls and removal is not out of the question. Were Vice President Victoria Villaruel--daughter of a Malvinas veteran, a Traditional Catholic, hated by the leftover Kirchnerites, described as a "conservative nationalist--to become president by default, Argentina would likely not prove to be an official welcoming safe harbor for Zionists. Research "Plan Andinia", but not using Wikipedia. The recent Patagonia fires haven't been forgotten and Milei's proposed legislation on sovereignty-surrendering land purchases by foreigners along with the fate of burned out forest lands failed to pass the legislature. The two provisions previously mentioned had to be modified and/or removed for possible passage of the rest. Instability in Argentina has grown significantly and an increasingly likely forced devaluation of the currency may be the straw that breaks the camel's back.

Phillip Legard's avatar

Interesting. If the Ukie lifeboat and the emergency Argentina lifeboat are both leaky, then leaving the ME isn't an option after all.

Guido Vandeven's avatar

Real problems will start after Putin realised his Novorussia and western Ukraine get an influx of all the surviving Nazis, Azovs and Melick battalions for so far that they aren’t being eaten by the grinding machine. Nobody can predict that the Colombian and Brazilian contractors will go home, who knows a South American drug cartel in the making, and what if western Ukraine isn’t going to be split up in a Polish, Romanian and who else is there exit Ukrainian state? There going to be much more problems after the war than during, but wait isn’t that what Europe always wanted…Drugs, children and organ trade, women trafficking and money laundering. The future might be bright for Europe but to achieve that goal Russia has to be defeated.

Alyosha's avatar

Ordinary Ukrainians will go after them. Rus formed SOF brigade from Ukrainian defectors and I am convinced that they will be tasked for the purge of Judeo-Banderite elites. Like in the good old times.

They sorted out old school Banderites, they sorted out Chechens, hunting them around the world.

Also, geniuses that Banderites are, they are bringing their "Gods" back to Ukraine, where they can easily pulverised in one place.

Guido Vandeven's avatar

but ordinary Ukrainians from where are you going to get them, when the educated, the elite and young generation will have fled to western sugar daddy. The elderly, the handicapped the psychological downtrodden are they going to clear Ukraine from its corruption?

Alyosha's avatar

Only people with connections and enough money can flee. OK, and some that manage to swim across a river or hike through the forests. Occasionally.

Ukraine will disintegrate, IMO. Nobody needs current Ukrainian "elite", they will cause problems everywhere they go. Which is going to be a sweet, sweet karma, if you ask me. They were "eliting" Ukraine since 1991 and they turned it into the poorest country in Europe even before the SMO.

With other words, Russia will sort out their Novorossia and parts of Malorossia and other countries will sort out their parts of the disintegrated Ukraine. Within different time frames and with different levels of success.

Alyosha's avatar

And this is why I think Ukraine will disintegrate.

https://unn.ua/en/news/the-ukrainian-national-pantheon-will-be-part-of-the-kyiv-pechersk-lavra-reserve-government-decision

Rus will take Kiev and end CIA's new Orthodox Church of Ukraine, created in 2019. Supposedly by a bribe of 20-25 million USD. Now that is another level of cognitive warfare.

The "Real Kievan Rus" will lose Kiev. lmao

Simon Robinson's avatar

Guido, whilst Russia may have a problem, I believe Western Europe will inherit an even bigger one as their domestic Police and/or Law enforcement structure have neither the training, capabilities nor capacity to deal with heavily armed, criminalised Nazis.

Alyosha's avatar

Anglos will also cover their backs. We are in for decades of Gladio 2.0.

Ukies are also not mentally ready for times when crocodile tears will be exhausted and they will be treated like ordinary Slavs again, with disdain. That will hurt their feelings. ;)

Victor's avatar

At least in Europe and the UK they will have DEI courts to support them.

Maria.'s avatar

If only the nazis neutralized the violent criminals implanted there, but no. Both will feast on regular citizens.

Rami Eskola's avatar

What 'Nazis' you are rambling about? Last living Nazis must be nearing 90 years by now. Who are calling nazis?

Ukrainians are calling Russian nazis and Russia is calling everybody else 'fascists'. Its idiotic. Very hard to decipher who are talked about because everybody is nazi or fascist.

Visceral Psyche's avatar

The Ukrainians are actual, like WWII actual, Nazis. They use the swastika, wolfsangel, and many other Nazi symbols, worship Stepan Bandera (who was a Nazi collaborator in WWII) etc. There's plenty of photos of vehicles and soldiers wearing the symbology of the Nazi regime of WWII. They are an ideological, direct continuation of the WWII Nazis.

Guido Vandeven's avatar

My personal opinion(s) and they’re not mandatory like in the most social media or the propaganda official media. Been living for 3 decades among a Jewish community with both very orthodox and also Israeli’s with double passports (Diamonds are forever), and unwillingly working with colleagues with Nazi sympathies, if not taking part in manifestations or being active in the greater European or international Nazi movement.

Let me first explain myself Simon, what you said about law enforcement and adequate police training towards Hooligans, Drug cartels, gangs, terrorists and Nazis. They can never win this war, that’s what is already happening in Marseille France, but also in many EU cities and the law enforcing govs admit that they fight an unequal war, it penetrates into the deepest core of our societies and Deep State!

Another point, many police are active members or have a past that goes back to Nazi sympathies, it is what it is and the same goes for the Armies. Forgive me my liberty for expressing my opinion but NATO is not a peaceful NA Trade Organisation, it is a Nazi Atlantic or transatlantic Terrorist Organisation. Nazism is not German but universal, in every country there are Nazis, even in Russia and the US and Israel. Israeli are perfect Kameleons they have adopted fully Nazism.

If you ask me to define Nazism again MPO, it’s everything except me-too, or me and you . It’s me against you, it’s only me against all others and the whole world, that’s what Israel has become and that’s what Nazi germany was in the past. They’re mirroring each other.

Who would ever thought that Israel, Israel First would become a Nazism state?

Oswald's avatar

There is the famous quip that the core of the Nazis was formed of homosexual, Jewish actors...

Jürgen Räche's avatar

That is precisely why Putin remarked in an interview in early August—paraphrasing here—"I am certain that Western Ukraine will soon be absorbed by its neighbors, who wish to reclaim their ancestral territories." The West immediately reacted with outrage, though Poland offered a meek rebuttal and Romania remained silent.

In that scenario, the problem of the Nazi element in those regions would become the EU's problem.

The real Nazi bigwigs—Azov and the like—have long since secured their assets; with their real estate and dollars, they would surely be welcomed in Canada...

As for the rank-and-file—the returnees from the front—they will realize who screwed them over... and I wouldn't want to be in the shoes of those who dragged civilians off the street for forced conscription... but that, too, will be the EU's problem.

Bob England's avatar

The real Nazi bigwigs are quite happy living it up, far from the front lines in the French Riviera and Cyprus driving around in their multi-million euro cars!

Jürgen Räche's avatar

True.

But they can be located and reached—especially by combat-hardened returnees from the front who are fully armed... the hunting down will start in their own country (what’s left of Ukraine) first, and then spread abroad.

Take Wildberries, for instance—Russia’s answer to Amazon (though not the largest of its kind in Russia; that would be Ozon). It is a company that was *not* attacked—and the reason why should be obvious to everyone...

( It is an American company. )

Anyway, Wildberries belongs to Russia’s richest woman—a woman who owns real estate in the very place where Zelenskyy once intended to spend his millions or billions of dollars; in other words, he was harming the very circles he once aspired to be part of.

Sources report that the Russian government pressured this woman *not* to place a bounty on Zelenskyy—something that would certainly have been within her means...

Yet another own goal for Zelenskyy... but he knows that once the war is over, his life is over too, regardless of who takes over...

As for who takes over then... Azov would be my guess.

Gisela's avatar

The Azovs in Canada, will have to learn to live peacefully with the Indian beach shitter hordes, currently exhausting the country.

Gary's avatar

No mystery why the criminal enterprise known as Israel is a safe haven for Jews with zero possibility of extradition for any crime. The country is a mafia safe house, skip out and land there and all your troubles are over.

Robert Alan's avatar

I believe that western Ukraine has felt warmly towards Nazis going back to WW-II..

BrzILO's avatar

Yes, I have also for a long time been of the opinion that Israel will want to evacuate the Middle East and create a Jewish state in Western Ukraine.

How the hard-core Banderites and their ilk will react to that remains to be seen. And I am also not sure that Russia would be too pleased about that possibility.

Victor's avatar

Jews will have a hard time justifying returning to their "homeland" after claiming Palestine as that homeland. I think think most will instead either return to their native lands where they came from or assimilate themselves into the new Palestinian state coming out of the dissolution of "israel".

The remaining settlers will return to New York City where they can hide among their own murderous kind and boast about how many Palestinian women, children and babies they killed or drove out of their homes.

Victor's avatar

Agreed until the last sentence. I don't believe that is going to happen. For one thing Z being Jewish as well as his team, means little - they are on their way out - forcefully probably. Secondly, Russia will have a big say in that as will the Poles, the Hungarians, and the Romanians all of whom have potential holds on the remaining lands that Russia does not take. And I think that no one wants another israel on their doorstep. And lastly, I haven't heard anyone in israel claiming such a desire.

So where do you get this information? Link please?

Proterran's avatar

Anyone who knows Israel and the true nature of present day Israelites has likely heard whispers of this or that plan, by this or that group. Among the privileged technically savvy educated Israeli classes (ie mostly Ashkenazi descendants but minus the culture thoe original Ashkenazis brought from Europe), it's not just talk but action as tens of thousands are leaving as soon as they can to wherever they can. Many are to be found in Berlin and the US coasts, especially those who could get jobs. Just about everyone and their brother in israel are in a mad pursuit of those coveted passports and those who can get them, often use the. Some leave for a while, come back, then leave again, but that segment of society really does plan to get the hell out, to wherever they can go that'll take them. Obviously Argentina is being talked about because fewer and fewer place even want them (like Thailand that has just about had enough of their shenanigans).

Among the ones who go back and forth are quite a few of those who immigrated from Russia and Ukraine in the '90s. There is already a trickle heading backwards to their original eastern Europe countries. Of course, there's no way the Russians will be happy to see an exodus of them who they were quite glad to see them depart. At some point in the near future, many say that Russia will eventually put its foot down on who can return and under what conditions. After all, during those years Israel kind of ruined the new generation that grew up there.

Ultimately, what that leaves behind in Israel are the religious, the zealot settlers, the poorer ones with no place to go to, and a few die hard "patriots" still attached to that country. For the most part, it'll be the true dregs of that society, the fanatics, the madmen and women that'll be left behind so sadly, the Palestinians will not benefit from the departure of the upper classes any time soon. If anything, things will get worse for them. The crazy left behinds will probably blow up the Dome in Jerusalem and who knows what else.

I believe this is also why there were whispers of West Ukraine, the old Pale. Perhaps somewhere in the depths of the mental dungeons of Israel, there is talk of new dragons. But no one I know takes it seriously.

Tony Leibbrandt's avatar

"For the most part, it'll be the true dregs of that society, the fanatics, the madmen and women..."

Rather unchivalrous of you, if not outright misogynistic, to classify all Israeli women "true dregs"!

Proterran's avatar

I should have said madwomen, shouldn't I have?

I am a woman myself, and no way would I discount the competence of women in the evil department - as history has shown, they are definitely the men's equals in cruelty and hunger for power.

Ain't equality great?

joehannes's avatar

It's a conspiracy theory that started to circulate in 2022. "Z is a jew, so he is making room for Jews!" or some nonsense like that. Classical disinfo-stuff for the "it's the Jews" narrative.

I agree. It is very doubtful that Jews will return to Eastern Europe in this century – after they've been removed from that part of the world so many times in such violent ways.

BrzILO's avatar

It is no link from anywhere. I came to that conclusion myself.

Here is my line of thought:

-The NATO-supported Ukrainian counteroffensive of 2023 failed miserably

-As the Mosad was involved in some way or other they realized that the NATO paper tiger (minus the nukes) was on it's way to diminished relevance (to a smaller or bigger degree).

-in order to make use of the remaining military might and support of the US Bibi came to the conclusion that he better start a major grass-mowing operation sooner rather than later

-to that effect he allowed (or arranged) the Hamas incursion

-bribed the US into electing DJT

-eventually dragged the US into war with Iran ( for Bibi it was now or never )

-the rest is history

Plus there has to be a reason why Israel and Russia are still on talking terms. The Western Ukrainian option needs to be available if the worse happens for Israel.

Just me thinking and reading between the lines.

Diego Garcia's avatar

The neoliberals in the US, and their ideological cousins in Europe, will only replace Zelensky with someone who will continue to push for fighting till the last Ukrainian while launching missiles at Russian infrastructure.

Jürgen Räche's avatar

Ukraine mirrors the exact state Russia was in during the Yeltsin and Gorbachev eras—the situation Putin encountered and was able to change, albeit very slowly and cautiously at first, until he was firmly enough in the saddle to take more aggressive action against the military and the oligarchs. The start of the Special Military Operation revealed where the "bad apples" in the General Staff were—men reeking of incompetence who had secured their posts through corruption and cronyism.

And Ukraine has remained stuck at precisely the point where Putin took over: everyone was on the take, from the ordinary worker to politicians and officers ranging from captain to major and colonel.

EXACTLY the scenario that was commonplace in Russia under Yeltsin and Gorbachev...

We... experienced it firsthand; you only know it from hearsay.

Since breaking away from the Soviet Union, not a single kilometer of new highway has been built in Ukraine, no subway lines have been expanded, and not one Antonov aircraft has undergone further development... nuclear power plants were no longer maintained responsibly—only patched up with makeshift repairs...

By the way, ALL of Ukraine's nuclear power plants were developed and financed by Russia... Ukraine didn't even assume its percentage share of the state debt... all of that was eventually settled internationally by Putin.

Robert Edwin House's avatar

we know what you're talking about, just take a look at california's "high speed" railway. America looks more like 1980'/90's soviet union then most americans realize.

Tatjana's avatar

Interesting, I also got the impression that they are planning to relocate Israel to Ukraine... (Unfortunatelly, I cannot remember what detail I noticed that made me think that. Maybe the ferwor the West is destroying Ukr. population and all the Kiev junta's ties with Isr.?)

joehannes's avatar

Israel will never relocate, because it is where it is. Maybe check the maps in the back of any Bible.

The Spectre's avatar

Israelis relocated after their temple was destroyed some 2000 years ago.

They will relocate again, this time for 3000 years. That long last danger level nuclear contamination made by Pakistan or Russia.

Some will stay there despite, as there are thousands deserters around Chernobyl nuclear plant. They prefer slow painful death from radiation and cancer, than fast death at front meat grinder.

joehannes's avatar

As I said, Israel is where it is. It cannot relocate because it is a piece of land that Jews consider theirs and call Israel. If the Jews left it, Israel would still be where it is.

The rest of your statement has no foundation in reality.

The Spectre's avatar

Some call it Palestine.

Some say world without borders, countries, governments, religions, armies

John Osman's avatar

If I am an Israeli wouldn't the USA, Western Europe or Latin America be preferable? What is left in Ukraine that makes it desirable?

Kennewick Man's avatar

‘Russian strikes could cause a mass exodus out of Kiev’

That would be a merciful endgame to this conflict, a lot better than dragging it out for more years. A lot better for Ukraine as well. Ukraine needs to think in terms of keeping their young men alive and gaining back their working age people from Western Nations. Their problem is that Z is not thinking in terms of Ukraine interests.

Tim's avatar

Indeed.

As a Talmudic scholar, he is solely concerned with that tract's dictates, ie that "Even the best of the Gentiles should be killed, as even the best of snakes should be killed."

Jürgen Räche's avatar

An empty city of Kyiv doesn't necessarily determine victory or defeat... Kyiv is only second in importance for Ukraine anyway; Odesa is far more important—and more important to the entire West, too.

The fate of Odesa—or its loss—spells the end of Ukraine as a state; for corporations investing in Ukrainian land and the like, it means either profit or total loss.

And who is it that calls the shots and holds sway across the West? Capital—and politicians (including the military) jump to its tune, even if it leads to their own destruction.

An empty Kyiv signifies only one thing—a mass exodus toward Lviv and beyond... thousands of refugees...

Yet this also constitutes a strategic weapon—a factor always present in both military and economic planning (look at Europe).

Tim's avatar

I'm assuming that deactivating Kiev would be fatal for command and control of whatever remains in Ukraine of a brain.

Bankova street being pretty crucial in that regard.

Kennewick Man's avatar

Kyiv is the undisputed cultural and economic center of Ukraine, dominated strongly by Ukrainian ethnics. Ukraine says it is 82% in a total of 3 million people, with additional possibly 2 million around the city. The city was barely touched upon the war and that allowed for the development of small interlaced manufacturing and assembly shops by the tens of thousands. They are functioning there under cover but the larger establishments are mapped by the Russians because of their ethnic presence. The general disruption of Kiev’s industrial activity is a deadly blow to Ukraine. As the refugees spread around struggling for living spaces the country will turn into a disorganized chaos, not a pretty site.

Yes, Odessa and ports is a critical component of the country but it seems the Russians blocked their activities with surprising easiness. The next logical targets will be the rail and road transportation hubs to Poland and Romania.

Feral Finster's avatar

At least during the years when I lived there, Kiev was hardly dominated by "Ukrainian ethnics".

joehannes's avatar

"An empty Kyiv signifies only one thing—a mass exodus toward Lviv and beyond..."

So an empty capital signals nothing about how the war is going? Western governments, investors and the public will read it as a demographic event and nothing more?

Jeannie's avatar

Government fleeing their capitol never looks good, but Russia at times left their own prize city Moscow in order to fight another day.

The Western puppeteers of this proxy war are interested in the fertile, mineral rich soil of the Donbas, and the Black Sea ports most of all. Without this, Kiev drops in importance.

joehannes's avatar

Zelensky and his backers certainly knew that access to the Black Sea would eventually be cut if they kept escalating. So why would the puppet masters keep doing it, if what they want is the Donbas and the ports?

GM's avatar
Aug 19Edited

What endgame?

How is it going to stop the drones?

New records have been set nearly every day this week. It reached over 1,600 yesterday.

You empty Kiev and what happens? The drones stop flying because... reasons?

What will stop the drones is shutting down the Polish border and enforcing deterrence by taking out the Ukronazis and sufficiently many of their Western backers.

But those are a higher category of human beings than ordinary Russians in the mind of the Kremlin so they are untouchable, and the Polish border cannot be shut down because god forbid bridges are burned with the higher category of human beings.

John Osman's avatar

GM. Your heart is not in it today is it?

TJE's avatar

dude...answer the fucking questions instead of coping...wtf

What he says is true and I've articulated this point he's hammering OVER AND OVER as well...the ground war is IRRELEVANT to the strategic conflict now

RF has not closed the Polish border nor developed the weapons to do so absent use of nukes. Meanwhile, AFU has succeeded in bringing RF drone launch pace down to less than 200 per day...while AFU launched thousands.

This is what EFFECTIVE ISR and EFFECTIVE strikes look like. They hit critical facilities and prevent necessary components from reaching supply points

John Osman's avatar

Dude.

How do the Russians close the Polish border? Criticising someone for not doing something they can't do seems a touch reductive.

The ground war isn't irrelevant, it's the decisive theatre. Blowing up Russia's Version of Amazon is irrelevant, in my opinion.

Are you saying that the Ukrainians are producing more drones than the Russians?

And why are drones important? Because they dominate the battlefield, which you're claiming is irrelevant. Make it make sense, Dude.

ThrowNat's avatar

1600 drones x median cost per long range ukie drone (60,000-200,000 USD) =150-200 million dollars per retarded ukie drone sortie, of which 1 to 5% strike any target whatsoever. Keep that pace up for a week and you're out a billion fucking dollars, and maybe you hit a handful of targets in Russia that they'll have fully repaired in under a month. Do some basic ass math instead of getting emotional, or in GM's case, don't take jew money to be an AGITPROP asshole.

Mikey Johnson's avatar

Didnt we leave the exodus thinking years ago? With all these kidnappings going on all over Ukraine, all these borders that is guarded as Fort Knox - whomis going to leave?

One after another European state is ”unasyling” those Ukrainians that fled the War. They are looked at as traitors.

If 2-3 million people leave Kiev for the countryside - what good will happen of that?

With 42 likes it reminds me of Jason Ardays masterful doctoral thesis; put in the word ”exodus” and ”merciful” and people goes banana.

The best way to not dragging it out for mote years is to obliterate Zelensky&Co.

Kennewick Man's avatar

‘The best way to not dragging it out for mote years is to obliterate Zelensky&Co.’

It is a difficult call. Throw it into Polymarket and you might be surprised by the results. Z is presently tending toward a much hated piano player, a strange little freak, foreign to the soul of Ukraine. His main strength was the hammering together of an international coalition and his weakness was always the fact that he is not an Ukraine ethnic. I never went through a detailed analysis of his military plans but if it turns out that he is not a military genius I will not be surprised. It is impossible to judge the possible outcomes of Z’s elimination. The optimal course from a Russian view is to allow the development of infighting around his miserable existence.

Jeannie's avatar

Western spook agencies will remove him when they have their next puppet agreed upon.

Larry Hill's avatar

The Novichok dose is already measured out, In Moscow-or LONDON..?

Mikey Johnson's avatar

Yeah, I was a bit rude, sorry for that.

I understand the perspective that Zelensky is the worst for Ukraine and good for the Russian outcome because his stubborn ”no retreat”, no land concessions and only Russian capitulation.

But my perspective has always been that he and his compatriots are bad for everything. The BS about ”dont make him a martyr” gives me Mossad vibes.

Ukraine seems to dig up their martyrs anyway and make PR-shows of it.

Russia did a lot of mistakes in 2022.

As soon as the Ukraine declined the Agreement of Istanbul in 2022 the Russian should have hammered him down. And every Western delegation entering Kiev.

Thats just cynical logic.

John Galtsky's avatar

While generally agreeing, I'd push back on "his weakness was always the fact that he is not an Ukraine ethnic"

As a matter of statistics, there is virtually nobody in the region formerly called "Ukraine" that was an "Ukraine ethnic". It's not really even an ethnicity except, to stretch the meaning of ethnicity, in a tiny handful of people in a handful of villages in three western regions of Ukraine. And, if *those* people are some sort of ethnicity they're different from each other given the historically great variation even in the dialect they spoke.

That's all been obscured by 12 years of fanatically violent Nazi propaganda that's been funded by many billions of dollars and powered by a willingness to kill tens of thousands of people, so there are many more people know in Nazi held territory that have studied hard or have been brainwashed hard and now think they are some sort of Ukrainian ethnicity, no matter that their native language is Russian and (except for the indoctrinated young) they speak the invented state Ukrainian language with a Russian accent.

Zelensky's weakness has always been that he doesn't give a shit about anything but himself, and certainly not the people his "Family" rules.

Kennewick Man's avatar

I do agree the whole of the Russo-Ukraine ethnic issue is a difficult one to sort out. The fact remains we are talking about a very large geographical area where the two groups existed in separation from the start of the Tatar invasions in the South. Still there are certain linguistic and cultural differences there the Ukrainians are valuing highly. I am fluent in a European language that changes accent and some word use every time you move like 30 miles in the country but it is still considered the same language.

Larry Hill's avatar

There are the Rus as historic fact. Some went east and some went west and some stayed around Kievan Rus foundation, and all had different experiences and influences.

Some like to emphasize cultural and ethnic influences or differences to exploit for some social or political objective, some others point to common origin and likenesses.

Duncan A Turner's avatar

Yeah. Lots of infighting. And pissed off people actually liking the possibility of their being more than one alternative to him so that "anyone except Zelensky!" becomes the dominant sentiment!

Kennewick Man's avatar

This is what I was bubbling about:

Ukraine’s Ex-Defense Minister Calls for Election, Cementing Break With Zelensky

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/19/world/europe/ukraine-fedorov-zelensky-elections.html

Feral Finster's avatar

We've heard predictions of a mass exodus several times in the past four years.

Larry Hill's avatar

Where are the Kiev residents and residents of most other city-dwellers gonna go?

Ahoy, EU, you got more chickens coming home to roost to join the legion of previous waves disrupted by all the other recent Western shortsighted regime change fantasies. You are really gonna have fun keeping the disgruntled Azov types entertained and rehabbed...

Enjoy!

John Osman's avatar

I agree Larry. It's going to be a huge problem.

areti spiropoulos's avatar

Their demographics are already shot. And doubtful many will return to an even further impoverished Ukraine. It was already the poorest most corrupt country in Europe before the SMO. Still poor still corrupt and now without a generation of men and resource rich lands. Mazel tov Ukraine.

Andy Francis's avatar

The Ukraine should not exist after this war is over.

Tim's avatar

Little discussed by mainstream media has been the role of Professor Jason Arday in the war thus far - he single-handedly co ordinated all missile defence forces deployed against the incoming Iskanders and Oreshniks, and now he has gone as a result of a racist witchhunt in Britain, the results are clear to see, particularly with regard to the storming of the Odessa port infrastructure.

Ukraine's remaining options have shrunk to the point where all that can now be done is to rearrange the seating in the Rada; which although effective and constructive, is unlikely to result in the sought-for victory over the Russian orcs.

quidestruetmundum's avatar

The idiot GenZ CIA employee who decided as part of the propaganda campaign to call Russian soldiers “orcs” like it’s the middle school bus. That fake-ass failed state can’t disappear into the dustbin soon enough.

Tim's avatar

The idiot DIE candidate who can't detect delicious irony even when it comes up and kisses him directly on the lips.

thatguy's avatar

It is my understanding that you are British, Tim. The British are known to have the best sense of irony and deadpan humor in the world. Considering the international composition of this forum, you might consider using a sarc tag. Otherwise you will have to "dumb down" the irony for everyone to get it without having to later explain it as such. But maybe it is more fun to see the dry irony going over some people's heads. Like "gotcha!".

Tim's avatar
Aug 21Edited

My mission is to raise the consciousness of the reader such that they too can appreciate the rhetorical form without having to have me explain it to them; which of course would completely destroy the exquisite pleasures associated with it.

It's all about teaching children; not humouring them.

I remember my elder son once saying "Dad!!" when I started to say something - he had learned what was probably coming just by the look on my face.

MaryJane's avatar

At least now we know where Ukrainians picked it up

Phillip Legard's avatar

To be fair, Arday did invent the Oreshnik, so he's bound to know its weaknesses.

Tim's avatar

First man to set foot on the moon, too.

Phillip Legard's avatar

I guess someone had to film Armstrong coming down the ladder.

Comrade Napoleon's avatar

Of course. They didn't invent the external camera mount yet.

Michael's avatar

Its all going to plan for the US. As if the US administrations are worried about their own proxies, just a meat grinder.

More entertaining is Israel, who people think controls the US LOL.

Waiting for Philippines to be the US meat grinder against China.

There are enough Wall St funded think tank papers and Wall St funded lobbying that pushes through what they want in congress

The funniest part is people think their vote matters…🤣🤣🤣

Tim's avatar

Anybody who thinks that Trump isn't controlled by Israel needs their head examined.

Michael's avatar

Nah..try examining the evidence. Do you need some?

Tim's avatar

$250 million from Adelson says otherwise.

Michael's avatar

Lol…so what? Thats so funny. Adelson represents Wall St you fool

Michael's avatar

As for trump biden clinton obama etc ALL MORONS who read scripts.

Michael's avatar

I can see why your gullible brain is easily manipulated.

rpn453's avatar

We're all on the same side. Let's be respectful (both of you!). It's reasonable to think either.

Personally, I think most nations are just tools of the lizards. But the people are great.

Michael's avatar

No we are not. I do not respect fools wanting to die for a Wall st lie.

You can

rpn453's avatar

Sorry, I must have missed something!

Just saying we all want a world of sovereign nations who respect one another's differences and compete fairly.

Michael's avatar

I cannot be respectful to a person who is brainwashed by narratives. I will retort in the same language given.

Michael's avatar

The people are not all great, they have been brainwashed.

Charles Langlois's avatar

Except you, of course. How do you manage it, tin-foil helmet?

thatguy's avatar

Trump serves both Wall St and Israel. It doesn’t have to be either/or. After all, Zionists are in charge of many Wall Street firms. But contrary to many, not every single firm on Wall St is 100% staffed by Jews only. The figure is more like 25%, iirc.

Trump has always been a very willing servant of both Israel and Wall Street. It isn’t like they are controlling him against his will, as many assert in a futile attempt to excuse his actions and betrayals to the original MAGA base.

Tim's avatar

All of them, whoever they have as figureheads, are owned by three jewish hedge funds.

You know their names.

Michael's avatar

Lol…no hedge fund controls all of Wall St. blackrock, vanguard, are the biggest and not jewish controlled.

State Street is also a big player, not jewish controlled.

Are you saying if a ceo is jewish it must be jewish owned controlled? Lol.

Comrade Napoleon's avatar

Remember that interview for Vogue magazine when jewlinskis wife proudly gushed that their 9 year old son gives his father military advice? I thought she was kidding.

https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-10872467/Zelenskys-wife-says-nine-year-old-son-gives-president-father-ADVICE-military-matters.html

Joshua Erwin's avatar

Better for Zelensky to win this power struggle, as he is unpopular. I'd guess he will too, he is like Macron. NATO/USA are trapped in there with him. They will probably have to unalive him.

Richard Roskell's avatar

I’m sure the war has made him rich beyond measure. But it’s difficult to see a future where Zelensky gets to enjoy it.

Jeannie's avatar

When they are done with him, they'll make sure his mouth stays shut, permanently.

Richard Roskell's avatar

The USA actually has a pretty good track record of looking after their puppets once they've served their purpose. (Think the Shah, Marcos...) But in Zelensky's case there's so much skulduggery involved with friend and foe alike that an early dirt nap is his likely fate.

Denis's avatar

Russia may be inflicting more pain than it receives, but Ukraine continues to be a nasty thorn in its side. I've omitted several other reports because it's Ukrainian sourced. Ukraine should have been dealt with long ago, but better late than never, I suppose. It was never a matter of Russia losing considering its six times bigger, but more a matter of how high the costs of winning would be, what would a win look like, and what will be the terms of peace. The jury is still out on that nearly 5 years into this costly SMO.

https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/ukraine-hits-key-russian-space-facility-flamingo-cruise-missiles

https://www.zerohedghttps://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/ukrainian-drones-launched-750-miles-deep-central-russia-kill-13

https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/ukrainian-drone-swarm-attack-obliterates-wildberries-largest-warehouse-near-moscowBREAKING:

Ukrainian long-range drones have struck Russia’s 3rd-largest oil refinery

Tatneft’s TANECO refinery in Nizhnekamsk in the Tatarstan region has a refining capacity of 17 million tons of oil per year. Only Omsk (22 million) and Kirishi (20 million) have more.

John's avatar

Hello Denis.

Ukraine was only a small part of the main goal. The security document that Russia sent to the West in December 21´ was the real deal. They are getting much closer to that objective now. My take.

Denis's avatar

Thanks for sharing, John.

Tony Leibbrandt's avatar

If only it were so. I see no evidence whatsoever of any movement in western/Nato policy towards "the real deal", no evidence of any "coming to their senses".

Barry McEntyre's avatar

Yeah it's the usual cope.

quidestruetmundum's avatar

Why are all pro-Ukrainians gay?

Denis's avatar

Thanks for your in-depth analysis, Dumdum.

Ooops, I mean Mundum.

John Osman's avatar

I think you were right first time, Denis.

thatguy's avatar

He was right the first time, but it was a lot funnier with the polite correction.

MaryJane's avatar

I actually heard kids ask this question

Nescio's avatar

The queen who could have answered the kids' question has recently passed away unexpectedly. Bummer.

MaryJane's avatar

I guess I missed something

Charles Langlois's avatar

"Ukrainian long-range drones have struck Russia’s 3rd-largest oil refinery"

but what damage did they cause? You quote the refining capacity as if the refinery had been entirely put out of action. Is that the case?

GM's avatar

1) Enough damage to cause another acute fuel crisis.

2) In other cases we do know what the damage is -- they hit the refinery in Orsk last week and the governor publicly stated that it was the "worst case scenario" because they hit the most critical part of the facility that is also imported so it will be out of action for at least six months.

3) The principle of the matter is most important. When the war started it was completely unthinkable for NATO to be doing a large-scale strategic bombing campaign on Russia because it was commonly understood that nukes would fly immediately in the other direction the moment NATO tried doing that. Now it is completely normalized, as is the lack of response. If you don't understand what a catastrophic development that represents for the Russian state and civilization, you cannot be helped.

Shagbark's avatar

No receipts. Just your bloviating.

Charles Langlois's avatar

"1) Enough damage to cause another acute fuel crisis."

Credible evidence, or it didn't happen.

2. That's not credible evidence. A direct hit on one refinery doesn't mean that all hits on refineries take out something critical.

3. Only important to you. What you fail to understand, with your "Russians are wimps and Putin is a fool and a traitor" obsession, is that NATO wants a war, because the military gets fed up with doing nothing, wars are political viagra and the potential spoils are huge, but Russia doesn't want to give them one. I know you are lusting after WWIII, but luckily, the Russian government has more sense. The older ones amongst them can still remember the last world war, unlike you, who seems to think its just like a video game only more real.

GM's avatar
Aug 19Edited

Are you being deliberately dense or you really are that dumb?

1) Follow the fucking war, please. It's not my job to do it for you.

Here are some references just from today:

https://t.me/barantchik/39687

https://t.me/barantchik/39699

https://t.me/barantchik/39698

2) The fucking Orenburg governor in a public announcement stated it. Here:

https://t.me/solntsev_official/6013

"Regarding the Orsk plant damaged by the terrorist attack, the situation there is grave. The shrapnel struck key infrastructure, which cannot be restored yet. The equipment is imported, and given the sanctions, repairs will take up to six months. The plant has been completely shut down. We are preparing for the worst-case scenario. We will have to rely on imported fuel. Logistics is already being reconfigured. Of the 287 gas stations, 80% are operational. As a reminder, emergency transport is the priority today."

That is not "credible evidence"?

And yes, Orenburg region immediately imposed fuel sale restrictions and they are still in effect as of today, a week later. That cannot be hidden.

3) It is important to every ordinary Russian from Crimea to now Omsk, with a tendency to expand further east. Because they used to live in a complete security safe in the knowledge that nobody will be firing drones and missiles at their homes and workplaces, and that if anyone tried to do that, he would get only a single chance, because he would cease to exist immediately.

Now that whole space, 2,500 x 2,500 km has been turned into a giant Syria because leadership turned out to be a bunch of traitors who started a war they had not intention of winning and now can't get out of it.

P.S. You know why you and so many others here are so quick to resort to the "you lust after WWIII" rhetoric? Because WWIII means your end. It doesn't mean an end for Russian people. Russia can annihilate all of Europe and the US will sit it out because it won't go to an all-out exchange. But then the US will fall apart due to civil war and internal unrest because it would not be able to mantain itself without sucking so much real wealth from the rest of the world. So if you are in Europe or the US, Russia fighting for real means a serious problem for you.

GM's avatar

Nukes would have flown immediately if NATO hit Samara with a missile at any point between around 1955 and 2021 (or perhaps some earlier time in Putin's reign given how the events after 2022 are forcing us to reassess his previous actions too).

Every single video or Substack post on this war should be primarily about how it happened that in 2026 NATO can freeily do missile strikes on the most sensitive Russian facilities and the Kremlin does not even acknowledge it, let alone respond in any way.

MaryJane's avatar

I wonder where you live to be so excited about nukes flying. New Zealand or Patagonia?

TJE's avatar

you cannot grasp the point, can you?

Russia TOLERATES strikes on critical strategic facilities...they have not even done what was necessary to make these capabilities redundant either. Single freaking plants, one in the country, that can do incredibly CRITICAL shit.

You understand that if the Soyuz plant is sufficiently damaged, the ENTIRETY of Russia's space comms and ISR buildout comes to a HALT, right?

Elena Newton's avatar

Perpetually baffling that you are almost the only one saying this.

Feral Finster's avatar

"Ukraine should have been dealt with long ago, but better late than never, I suppose. "

How many premature predictions of victory have we seen before already?

Denis's avatar

I've lost count, Feral.

No one expected it to last this long.

Russia keeps on winning but when will it finally have won?

What will having won look like?

At what cost?

Terms of peace?

Will the popcorn get eaten or go stale waiting?

Will Ukraine still stand to fight again?

Feral Finster's avatar

Reading old Simp articles is hella depressing.

Fulano's avatar

We desperately need a new frontline update.

CC's avatar

What for? I don’t think anything that happened in the front line in the last year of longer has been of any consequence beyond the personal loss to the poor souls stuck there on both sides.

Jullianne's avatar

The immediate reason for framing the problem as a shortage of defence for Kiev AND SOLVE THAT ONE OR APPEAR TO, is to avoid that massive exodus of people heading west over the winter impacting the sentiments of ordinary people in the west AGAINST Ukraine and also giving western governments the horrendous problem of actually dealing with these people.

If Kiev can be defended the argument goes at least enough to keep these people there and not here, and avoid Russia actually rolling in and bringing it all to an end, that is the best we can hope for in terms of surviving the winter. Then who knows what might turn up. This is the Micawber policy that has distinguished euro-NATO (the new euro only NATO, that is also despairing of its hope of some fudge in the ME to bring Trump's focus back on their war and helpfully relieve US angst over weapons shortages.)

Tim's avatar

I honestly think that there is no real belief in Ukraine's ability to defend itself - only a belief that the longer the war goes on, the more graft can be achieved by everybody from Z on down.

Europe is closing its doors to any new refugees, especially males of fighting age, so one wonders what the eventual outcome will be, other than mass deaths due to starvation and disease.

The 4 horsemen always come riding by in the wake of wars.

This is Ukraine's future.

Charles Langlois's avatar

Indeed, Ukranians should stay in Ukraine and fight there and die there. The West hasn't been bankrolling a war all these years just to give the inhabitants of the most corrupt country in Europe an excuse to get the hell out.

GM's avatar
Aug 19Edited

There is no problem with a shortage of air defense in Kiev.

It is very convenient for the Kremlin to have that topic take up so much information space so that it distracts from the escalating strategic bombing campaign deep inside Russia.

But in reality it doesn't matter if Kiev has or doesn't have air defense, thus there is no problem it it doesn't.

Russia could hit anything it wanted even when Kiev was well supplied with Patriot interceptors. But everything important was, and conitnues to be, off-limits because Putin was ordered to not touch it by his masters in Tel Aviv. Which is clearly a much stronger protection than any AD system. No object in Russia enjoys a similar level of protection.

Anything else Russia can bomb at will, make the city uninhabitable, etc., it doesn't matter. The purpose of Ukraine is to be a launch platform for drone and missile strikes into Russia. It doesn't need civilians or industry to do that, because the drones and missiles are made in Europe and North America, and those locations are also untouchable, because again, Putin has his orders from his real masters.

Also, notice how in 2024 we were regularly seeing videos of Patriot systems being blown up in Kiev and elsewhere. Why haven't we seen that in a very long time? Because we really haven't seen it, have we? Well, what appears to have happened is that the Patriot systems themselves also got moved into the list of objects off-limits for strikes. And that happened once Trump took power. Because every time a Patriot system is taken out, the Americans who operate it die. And we can't upset our dear partners, can we? Or should it be feudal lords? The last time a HIMARS TEL was taken out was also a very long time ago even though Russia now has drone with real-time guidance that fly very deep into Ukraine.

Jullianne's avatar

I understand how difficult the current reality is for you to accommodate to your preferred narrative. Condolences.

John Osman's avatar

Julianne. I was thinking the same thing.

He is just going through the motions today isn't he?

Tim's avatar

You're daft as a brush, GM.

The reason why no Patriots are being taken out in Kiev anymore is because there aren't any left.

Not that they are efficacious anyway, as the Iran situation has shown.

I ( used to ) watch the Tanya-Fiona YT channel; she blogs from Kiev on a constant basis; and she says that there are no longer any interceptions of Iskanders and cruise missiles - they all now get through.

So much for Tel Aviv giving Putin his instructions.

GM's avatar

>The reason why no Patriots are being taken out in Kiev anymore is because there aren't any left.

You have no clue what you are talking about.

There is a difference between interceptors (of which there are very few) and air defense systems (which are there).

And those air defense systems have been there throughout all this time and have shot down quite a few Russian missiles.

But while in 2024 they were systematically hunted and destroyed, for the last 18 months they have not been touched.

John Skiffer's avatar

Great to have you as a trustworthy source on the ground in Kiev that can verify things first hand.

Tim's avatar

Illogical.

When I say there are no more Patriot systems in Kiev to be taken out, that is what I am talking about.

I am not talking about other AD systems.

It's called basic comprehension of English.

Rob10's avatar

GM is an interesting character. He pays attention to what we are not seeing. Nobody knows if and how many Patriots there are in Ukraine but we are not seeing any hits on them by the Russians. We are not seeing that the Russians are taking care of the instigators or real factories in the West. In fact we are not seeing much activity along a supposed front line of more than 1000 km. An insertion of a few armored vehicles is called a serious attack, Are you kidding me? In the Gulf a lot of tankers are supposed to be hit by both Iran and the US. Where are the beaches with all the oil contamination as is supposed to happen after these strikes? Empty tankers? Decoys? Fake? From Orwell's 1984: The war is intentionally endless and serves to consume surplus goods and keep the populace in a state of constant fear and scarcity.

TJE's avatar

why would you see hits on a system that would not be deployed?

PAC interceptor scarcity is not a new thing in Ukranus.

TJE's avatar

uh...ok, slow down man

Patriot "systems" do not get destroyed- components of those systems occasionally do. The typical hits are launchers and radars, NOT the control truck.

The reason that these systems haven't been seen being hit is the SAME as Putin's defense of Moscow- political. Jelensky's hold on power cannot survive uprising anymore than anyone else's can.

Patriot has been low on inventory in Ukranus, on ration, for a good while now. This isn't a new thing. Consequently, the systems have been retreated to Kiev and put into underground facilities to preserve them.

Patriot USED TO shoot down Su34s- we have that famous recording of the air controller with the Su34 pilot who managed to dodge a PAC ("Patriot is illuminating...maximum RPM brother"). The interceptors were more abundant, thus the systems were moved FURTHER FORWARD. They could be struck there. Particularly, launchers....less frequently radars. Rarely an entire battery is colocated for obvious reasons.

Again, judge ACTIONS- Patriot stopped hitting non-ballistic targets...this was evidence of munitions scarcity FIRST. It led necessarily to less *need* to hit those systems as they were inoperable, plus these systems could not be deployed just to sit there idle. Surviving launchers have been moved into protection. Radars are still in use. Command facilities are in hardened bunkers now.

No risk to any theoretical American operators (very few are doing it anyway)

GM's avatar

They used to be hit though.

In Kiev.

There were multiple videos of Patriot batteries firing dozens of interceptors in a desperate attempt to save themselves, then the Zircon/Kinzhal hit right where the fireworks were coming from.

That stopped at some point.

But Patriots were definitely firing at Iskanders and even hitting some portion of them.

So it absolutely made sense to continue taking the Patriots out, whethere it's launchers, radars, whatever. They do have Gerans with real-time optical guidance that can fly over Kiev now.

But no Patriot has been touched in a long time, and it does seem to me that the "long time" in question coincides with Trump taking power and Kushner and Witkoff starting their series of trips to Moscow.

Antipodes's avatar

This requires old school pan popped corn, not that mircrowave variety.

And lashings of butter.

John's avatar

Quite a circus in the Occident between Ukraine and Iran. For things to have gotten to this point, I knew there were severely negative possibilities. But, to actually get this spaced out and completely unhinged.? ............ unbelievable. What now Batman? Was there noone else but a guy who thought he was funny and his talent on the piano was with his genitals? Absolutely crazy.

Tim's avatar

Ask Vicky.

She was the genius who selected the cast of characters.

John's avatar

Hey Tim.

Oh, Victoria N. She is a set of numb nuts, another one who could not venture past the crayon boundaries. I think it was all set up in the ashes of europe after WWII. This type of gross stupidity and arrogance takes a long time to develop. These people who created the plan and mechanisms are long dead so, the zombies are running wild.I just never imagined there were so many zombies. My view of her.

Tim's avatar

She's a jew, which explains everything.

Her husband is Kagan, one of the very worst of them.

John's avatar

I am of Irish decent but, I grew up with Jews. They weren´t anything like these fools. I was well treated by a number of them. These clowns are not Jews in my book. They are just trash. It is more complicated than simple hatred and I will not ignore that.

John “JohnNY K” Kaeser's avatar

They are "Neo-cons"(Neoconservatives), Paul Wolfowitz, Richard Peele, V. Midland, her husband Richard Lagan and others, who would love nothing more than to expand the US Hegemon to the particioning of Russia into subservient sub-states! That the overriding mentality of these "Jackels"!

Pedro's avatar

Excellent report.